diiz wrote:popeye1234 wrote:You have a technical hitch, playback for those samples should be at perfectly acceptable level.
Try using RGC Audio SFZ player.
Learn to use a USB midi keyboard. Just at a very basic level should help, just keying into the DAW produce lacklustre results if you do not even get the relationship of the notes in a more meaningful way. Orchestral music requires changes in dynamics shifting from soft & gentle to powerful and loud, swift micro changes in tempo; not just painting notes on the screen on a wing and a prayer.
Get one with at least 49 keys, any less is extremely limiting. You will not have to be a virtuoso, though of course that would help!
Read some consumer reviews of entry level 49 key (and above) keyboards. If you want to do orchestral music (or Piano or Synth) get a sustain pedal. They are cheap to buy and very useful.
Well, some of the greatest classical pieces have been composed with nothing but a quill pen and paper... and in some cases, by deaf guys
I don't know if it's strictly a requirement to use a MIDI keyboard for any kind of music. It can make things easier and faster, but on the other hand, there's no benefit in it if you don't have any skill in playing the keyboard... and arguably, when you're forced to enter notes one-by-one in a sequencer, you'll be forced to pay more attention to each note/chord, and you'll be able to get every note where you want, with the velocity you want.
I know you are sort of joking about this, but lets run with this. Beethoven (deaf at the end of his life) was a skilled keyboardist. He understood the relationship of notes arguably better than anybody! Beethoven was schooled in music and performance from a very young age. Beethoven would compose with a keyboard. Actually some composers only got to hear keyboard performances of their work.
He understood music on an incredibly deep level. Genius composers like this can look at a musically score and hear the results in their heads. They can imagine how each musician will handle each musical phrase.
I do not believe that any piece of Orchestral music worth listening to has ever been
written by an amateur (dragging note blocks in a DAW) one that is
both totally incapable of playing any instrument and also does not understand proper musical notation. You do not have to be remotely good at the keyboard to get started but pressing keys on a keyboard allows you to at least hear a rough impression of what you are trying to convey.
If you can think of anyone lacking both skills that has written a great (or even half decent) Orchestral piece (not cloned) please point me to an example.
However there have been composers who could no longer play an instrument due to injury but could compose. Also there are fantastic musicians and composers who cannot read music, such as Vangelis.
There are guys who do not use a midi keyboard to input the music that can compose music with a DAW. They can all play instruments and know music. Also they all know that better results will come from performing the notes with instruments too.
Have a listen to the work of this guy. He can do both of course:
http://guybacos.com/demos.php