LMMS • Forums

Well, I just loaded up DSK ChoirZ to test it, and it plays in the exact same pitch as triple osc, the key change works fine. No problems whatsoever.

So this is probably a problem only with the windows version. Or even only with the 64bit windows version.

sti2nd wrote:popeye1234 solved it by moving the green box 7 semitones to the left, as I have to with DSK Akoustik Guitar.

It would of course be cool if we found out why some VST's (or most of them) doesn't correspond natively with LMMS. They all follow another standard, or what?

Hi Sti2nd,
Well no, it still has this problem.
This did not work at all in 0.4.15. That (current) version refuses to allow you to do that (32bit or 64bit) with vestige VST. At least that is what happens (or more accurately doesn't happen!) with Windows 7 64bit.

I can move the green box in 0.4.13 and achieve this. HOWEVER - that version is unstable with drop out and random crashes (often just loading the program up).
So I have gone back to version 15 there I have to alter the pitch each and every time I load the program since the effect of saving the setting isn't actually recorded. The pitch figures is saved (say -12) but it goes back to the same wrong pitch next time you load it, even though it shows -12.

diiz wrote: Well, I just loaded up DSK ChoirZ to test it, and it plays in the exact same pitch as triple osc, the key change works fine. No problems whatsoever.
So this is probably a problem only with the windows version. Or even only with the 64bit windows version.

Thanks for checking this Diiz.
Yes I have found other users have had the same issues with LMMS using 64bit operating systems.
Using the 32bit version with 32bit VSTs only does not solve it.
To reiterate, this is definitely a problem specifically with LMMS. Non of the other DAW software I have tried has suffered this strange pitch problem with any VSTs thus far.

Fingers crossed this is something that gets solved in the next version. Somehow I doubt it.

Well, your best bet is to file a bug report on github.

https://github.com/LMMS/lmms/issues

Describe the issue as thoroughly as you can, remember to include all relevant information - your hardware, operating system, LMMS version. It may or may not get fixed in time for next release - depends largely on whether anyone can replicate the problem, which can be hard when it only affects a certain build on a certain OS - AFAIK most developers don't use Windows.

In the meanwhile, since you have access to other DAW's that work on your system, it's probably better for you to use those. The only other option is to change your OS, but unless you really REALLY want to get LMMS working, that's probably a bit overkill.

yes- must be only win and only 64bit.
Oatmeal is in perfect harmony with lmms-outofthebox 3os, in win32-0.15.
Refere to this post, when you report your bug.

I have just reported this as recommended. Not expecting an immediate solution.
I did link it to this conversation, given the confusion it seems a no brainer to do this.

Regarding what developers use for this I think the clue is in the name Linux Multi..................

Diiz,
Slight confusion, I have opened up an issue as recommended but it now appears to have disappeared from the list it was on, or it has been removed from the issue list with no updates or comments.
Perhaps I am looking in the wrong place?

My post:
https://github.com/LMMS/lmms/issues/9

However it already appears to be gone from the list of issues:
https://github.com/LMMS/lmms/issues?lab ... state=open

Could this mean the it is a known issue and has already been solved for the next release but they do not want to say when this will happen

I can see it there just fine.

https://github.com/LMMS/lmms/issues

popeye1234 wrote:Diiz,
Slight confusion, I have opened up an issue as recommended but it now appears to have disappeared from the list it was on, or it has been removed from the issue list with no updates or comments.
Perhaps I am looking in the wrong place?

Your link goes to a filtered version of the list, only showing issues labeled "enhancement/patch". Click the label in the left edge of the page to clear it.

raekman wrote:

popeye1234 wrote:Diiz,
Slight confusion, I have opened up an issue as recommended but it now appears to have disappeared from the list it was on, or it has been removed from the issue list with no updates or comments.
Perhaps I am looking in the wrong place?

Your link goes to a filtered version of the list, only showing issues labeled "enhancement/patch". Click the label in the left edge of the page to clear it.

Okay, thanks guys.

The new LMMS 0.9.90 still has this terrible problem.