Ah, that makes sense.popeye1234 wrote:Lets start with something different; Do you know about notation software?
http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/reviews/soft ... re-review/
http://davidbolton.info/articles/musescore_review.html
https://sourceforge.net/projects/mscore/reviews/
http://musescore.org/
Audacity is mostly for editing WAV files.
If you are not recording voice or live instruments with microphones or using a midi keyboard plugged into the PC or any other midi device then Audacity may not be required at any point. But check it out anyway.
If you want to record midi data to edit in the DAW use piano roll functions in a DAW, such as LMMS. The data remains very small as it is instructions to play sounds rather than an actual recording.
If however you want to record the performance as if playing live then Audacity will allow you to do this. It does not have to be a finished product, you can cut and edit tracks (as you can with multi track tape in a studio) but it isn't as simple as rubbing out or moving individual notes in Piano roll.
Also the Piano roll info could be recorded alternatively as musical notation and could be a worthwhile learning experience for a musician such as yourself.
In your position I would look at composing with notation software.
http://www.notionmusic.com/products/notion4.html
free alternative (doubt it comes with quality sound software):
http://musescore.org/
Playing and recording with Audicity or Wavasour is a totally different experience, more like the old days in a studio (but quicker and easier to edit) before DAWs changed the game, at least for Pop (and Orchestral mock ups or say TV work). If you are experimenting it will take a lot longer.
If you get a midi keyboard you could use both. Both have significant advantages. Recording a performance with a WAV editor allows you to play with greater expression much of which disappears when you fill in notes in a Piano roll.
I've used musescore before, but not for things like this. What do you mean when you say the piano roll info could be recorded alternatively as musical notation though? How does that work? I would love to learn about that too. Thanks for your help.