Anyone interested in Heroic Selects?

[caLRo]

https://www.reddit.com/r/heroicrecordin ... be4a1a78a7

If you're familiar with Spinnin' Records Talent Pool or something similar, then you'll know what this is about. If you're interested, give it a shot. I have listened to the BoLV3 tracks, I know many of you are talented.

[mrlmmsguy]

Here are some other places to get exposure and/or feedback, all with 50 - 100 members:
https://soundcloud.com/groups/honest-feedback
https://soundcloud.com/groups/the-truth-cannon
https://soundcloud.com/groups/brutally- ... es-welcome
And this sucker has 30,000+ members
https://soundcloud.com/groups/100-feedback-all-genres

[caLRo]

Those groups are not moderated, which makes them less reliable. You can use them to get some plays, but feedback isn't guaranteed (even when it says it is).

A talent pool has the added value that participants have a chance to win something in addition to getting feedback and exposure. Compared to those unmoderated SC groups, there's usually a higher chance to get good and useful feedback, because these talent pools are hosted by a record label. In my opinion, one of the best things you can get out a talent pool (besides the winning prize) is this expert feedback.

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=3564#p12018
In the past, I have condemned these talent pools. While I still think there are some obvious drawbacks, I do like the democratic and low-barrier approach. See it as a stepping stone towards getting signed up with a label, should you want to pursue that.

The term 'talent pool' is a bit misleading, because it's not entirely about talent and musical skill. You need to get people to upvote your demo in order to win, which makes it more of a popularity contest.

Has anyone participated in such talent pools? Want to share your comments/thoughts?